Claude Skills Silently Override Instructions: Undocumented Pitfalls Exposed
A Reddit user digging into Claude Skills found multiple silent behaviors that override explicit instructions, with no documentation in skill-creator. Here's what they uncovered.
Key Pitfalls in Claude Skills
ask_user_input_v0hard limits: The tool enforces a maximum of 3 questions and 4 options per question. If a skill requests more, Claude silently compacts them. No error is raised.- File write inconsistency: On Code/Desktop,
Writesilently overwrites existing files. On Claude.ai,create_filerefuses to overwrite. Same instruction, opposite behavior. - Relative paths in
references/are broken: The officially recommendedreferences/pattern doesn't resolve relative paths from the skill's directory on any platform. - Silent fallback for missing tools: If a skill references a tool that doesn't exist on the running platform, Claude falls back to prose without any error or warning.
Practical Fixes
The author's fix: update skills to ask multiple rounds when more input is needed, bypassing the ask_user_input_v0 limits. For file operations, always use Write on Code/Desktop and create_file with platform checks on Claude.ai. Avoid relative paths in references/; use absolute paths or inline content instead.
Community-Shared Repo
Findings are being collected in a GitHub repository: github.com/livlign/claude-skills-pitfalls. Contributions welcome.
Who Should Care
Anyone building or maintaining Claude Skills, especially those relying on user input flows or cross-platform behaviors.
📖 Read the full source: r/ClaudeAI
👀 See Also
HF Viewer: Visualize Any Hugging Face Model Graph Instantly
HF Viewer is a browser-based tool that renders an interactive architecture graph for any Hugging Face model. Paste a URL or repo name, inspect the graph without local setup.
Rift CLI: Manage Git Worktrees for Parallel AI Agent Workflows
Rift is a CLI tool that creates isolated Git worktrees and branches to run multiple AI coding agents like Claude Code simultaneously on the same repository. It includes lifecycle hooks, deterministic port mapping, and multi-editor workspace support.
OpenClaw-Mem0 Plugin Adds Persistent Memory Outside Context Window
The openclaw-mem0 plugin moves memory storage completely outside OpenClaw's context window, preventing loss from compaction or session restarts. It provides automatic recall and capture with both cloud and local setup options.
AI Doomsday Toolbox v0.932 adds benchmarking, dataset creation, and agent workspace for Android local AI
AI Doomsday Toolbox v0.932 introduces benchmarking for local LLMs on Android devices, a dataset creator that converts text/PDF files to Alpaca JSON format, and an AI agent workspace with Termux integration. The update also includes subtitle burning with Whisper and built-in Ollama management tools.